Pitchball cards are one of the collectible types in The Outer Worlds 2. There are a handful of them you can find all over of the open world of the game. There are over 20 Tossball and Pitchball cards you can collect in The Outer Worlds 2.
But unlike other collectibles these actually have a purpose outside just being collectibles. When picked up they offer permanent stat boosts when picked up.
They serve as part of a collectible system which ties into a side-quest: you collect a number of them to unlock extra content (“A Collection of Rogues” quest) via NPC Fionna F. Walker at Free Market Station.
Pitchball Card #1: Alex Wilson Location
Where: Paradise Island
The Alex Wilson Card is on a wall inside the Fairfield Saloon on Paradise Island.
Pitchball Card #2: Ben Hamilton Location
Where: Paradise Island
The Ben Hamilton trading card is sitting on a chair up on a cliff in Sovereign’s Sweet Spire Grove. The best way to get it by playing a side quest called “A Final Death for Gravity” and platforming up the huge rocks. However, you need to use the double jump ability to reach this location in The Outer Worlds 2.
Pitchball Card #3: Chris Stanick Location
Where: Paradise Island
The Chris Stanick trading card is in Deck 4 inside the Skycutter. Look for it on a table in the south.
Pitchball Card #4: Kyle Koenig Location
Where: Paradise Island
The Kyle Koenig trading card is inside the Arbiter Training Facility. You need to pick it up from a table inside the facility. The Arbiter Training Facility is right next to the firing range.
Pitchball Card #5: Laela Russell Location
Where: Free Market Station
Laela Russell trading card is found inside the Free Market Station. You can find it inside a room which is to your right after coming down the ramp near your ship.
Pitchball Card #6: Mark DeGeorge Location
Where: Paradise Island
Go west from the Fairfield Clinic until you spot a scarecrow in a field. This scarecrow is holding the Mark DeGeorge trading card in its hand.
Pitchball Card #7: Matt Booty Location
Where: Free Market Station
The Matt Booty card is sold by Card-Collector’s Curios but only after giving 15 cards to Fionna in the Saloon at Free Market Station.
Pitchball Card #8: Nathan Lawter Location
Where: Horizon Point Station
You can pick this card up during “A Cause Worth Killing For mission.” It is inside a room on the Security Ops – Main Level, the same location where we use the Mag-Pick on a locked locker.
Pitchball Card #9: Tony Blackwell
Where: Free Market Station
Go to the 2nd Choice Bar in the Free Market Station and you will see the Tony Blackwell card behind Fionna.
Pitchball Card #10: Trevor Swafford Location
Where: Paradise Island
Sitting on top of a house between Fairfield and the Ministry of Accuracy.
Pitchball Card #11: Yilan Tang Location
Where: Free Market Station
Go to the very center of the Free Market Bazaar in Free Market Station. There is a table there that has the Yilan Tang on it.
As I find more cards the guide will be updated as we go.
